It seems the writers of The Gift Of Sleep eBook are banning anyone who dares suggest their methods be anything other then loving from their Facebook, twitter, and YouTube pages.
I have two things to say about it.
1. Don’t publish a book if you cannot accept criticism
That’s pretty straight forward but I’ll elaborate a little.
I’m a “mummy blogger” as in I write about my opinions on parenting and share a little of my parenting journey. From birth to breastfeeding to behaviour and boo boos (see what I did there with the Bs
) I write about what interests me and what is relevant to my family. Over time that has evolved. When I first starting blogging it was about boobs and birth trauma, with some other stuff thrown in the mix. I put it out there because I thought it was important.
And most of the feedback was just ace. Lovely people supporting me and sharing their own journeys.
Some of the feedback was critical and questioning, that’s also okay. I answered honestly and engaged them in open and frank discussion.
The only comments I ever deleted were personal attacks or just down right rude comments filled with racism, sexism, profanity or just hate filled rants.
But I expected people to question my parenting methods if I chose to talk about them in a public way.
Yes, some of it was harsh and at times a little hard to deal with, but I expected it.
If the authors of The Gift of Sleep are comfortable with their chosen parenting method then they will allow others to question it and then in return will engage them in frank and open discussion.
Let’s be real Mia and Elizabeth, you’re peddling the same old snake oil that baby trainers across the western world have been flogging for a while now. Ignore the protest cries and respond to the distressed cries. We’ve heard it. We get it.
It’s still ridiculous.
You see in a baby every cry is a form of communication.
But more on that a little later.
The second reason why I am worried about the blocking is this.
2. What have they got to hide?
I started this blog with the intent of being open and honest about what attachment parenting is all about. I’ve shown my struggles, I haven’t always painted with every colour of the rainbow. I’ve posted during wonder weeks about how damn tough it is.
Why? Not because I want to sway people away from attachment parenting or even parenting in general, but because I believe parents should have all the information about parenting before making choices so then they have realistic expectations.
If The Gift of Sleep is really as good as they say it is, why are they worried about criticism. What are they hiding? Why aren’t they upfront about the fact that it is controlled crying?
Let’s be honest, if a sleeping method involves crying that is timed by the parent before it is responded to is controlled crying.
There’s nothing wrong with calling controlled crying controlled crying, some parents will choose that method. There is something wrong with calling it something else simply to sell books to unsuspecting parents.
Woops. eBooks.
They’re also not upfront about the authors qualifications either. That also sends up alarm bells.
Pick a parenting author who is upfront and honest.
Dr Sears, is a doctor, paedatrition in fact. And he’s open and honest about it. You could even go and see him in his practice and see his license on the wall if you wanted.
Pinky McKay is a lactation consultant, and is endorsed by the Australian Breastfeeding Association.
Elizabeth Pantley is just a mum. Sorry mom, she is American after all. But she is up front about that. She presents the methods that worked for her family in a honest way and without a scrap of judgement.
Tizzie Hall? I think she was a nanny. Apparently she did a unit of study on psychology. Yet she makes huge statements about breastfeeding. Okay then.
Elizabeth Sloane? Who knows. I’m not willing to pay $19.95 to find out. Maybe she’s an expert in door knocking or carpet scratching.
Mia Freedman? She’s a shrill woman from the suburbs of Sydney who practices a form of detached parenting that makes me cringe and claims to be a voice for Australian mothers. I wish she’d just buggar off into obscurity to be honest.
And now picture this.
It’s dark, cold, and someone is crying. Their carer, sitting in another room is drinking a glass of wine and watching TV ignoring the cries.
The person crying is getting louder and louder, the carer looks at their watch. It hasn’t yet been 5 minutes so she refuses to go in.
The person crying is sweaty, has a headache from the crying, is distressed, but had to wait. The book says this is the only way.
Eventually the crying stops, the carers toast their success. In the dark room, perhaps the person is asleep, maybe they’ve just given up. They lay their in the darkness, heartbroken, no one is coming.
Why is that okay if it is a baby being ignored by their parents, but not okay if it is an elderly person being ignored by nursing home workers or a handicapped person being ignored by their carers?
Why is it disrespectful to ignore a crying adult but not a crying baby?
It is simple. Baby trainers don’t award babies the same status of personhood that they do adults and older children. They are simply a problem to be managed and their unhappiness a tool to make them some serious dollars. No other group can be as marginalized or as discriminated against as children are, because they don’t have a voice.
He’s not giving you a hard time, he’s having a hard time.
Parents check your ego at the delivery room door because it’s not all about you anymore. Truth is having a baby will change your life in more ways then buying cute outfits or rearranging your schedule to fit in gymbaroo. You will be tired, you will have little time to yourself and you will spend a lot of time consoling a cranky baby. Your fussy baby may infact just be a normal kid. Relax, one day they’ll leave home and then their sleep won’t be your problem any more.
However choose what you do in the mean time with great care. Babies are resilient, they do bounce, rolling off the bed one time won’t doom them to a life as the village idiot… Routinely and repeated ignoring of your child’s attempts at communication can have serious negative effects on their mental health. Secure and loving attachment is vital.
This doesn’t mean you have to cosleep or breastfeed until college, however if you find yourself scratching the carpet while your babies cries for you just ask yourself, would I treat a friend like this, and if I did would we be friends for very long?








